Making Shampoo Bars

The Best Shampoo Bar Recipe for All Hair Types

Making Shampoo Bars

Reading Time: 7 minutes

Making shampoo bars is a very different process from making body soap in a lot of ways. Unlike body soap, it is important to limit the number of unsaponifiable substances in a bar made for hair. Unsaponifiable substances are the parts of an oil besides the fatty acids. The fatty acids will react with the lye to form soap, but the unsaponifiables remain unchanged. Too much unsaponified matter when making shampoo bars means a sticky film left on the hair after washing. Some oils have a lot of unsaponifiables, such as unprocessed shea butter. Some are naturally low in unsaponifiables, like cocoa butter. The best shampoo bar recipe will have a very low amount of unsaponified substances.

Another difference between making shampoo bars and body bars is that you want to use larger amounts of strong bubbling oils, such as castor and coconut oils, to effectively lift and separate the strands of hair and to attach to grime, allowing it to be washed away. The best shampoo bar recipe will have no more than 50 percent soft oils, such as canola, rice bran, soybean or olive oil, and a high percentage of coconut and castor oils for rich bubbles. If you do not know how to make coconut oil soap, it is important to keep in mind that high coconut oil formulas can overheat easily during gel phase, especially if you have a recipe with honey or sugar. Another difference with high coconut oil soap is that the soap may harden more quickly than usual, and can often be cut the same day it is poured into the mold. (If you find yourself asking, “how does soap work?” click here for more information on the soap making process.)

The cured shampoo loaf is an ivory color. Photo by Melanie Teegarden.

When making shampoo bars, they should not be superfatted to a high percentage like body soaps, because the residual oils can weigh the hair down. The best shampoo bar recipe will have between 4-7 percent superfat, enough to make the shampoo gentle and to use up all of the lye for soap, but not enough to coat the hair. The recipe contained within this article is for 6 percent superfat.

Below is the best shampoo bar recipe of all that we tried. It was tested on oily and dry hair types, as well as both fine and coarse hair types. The majority of those who tried the sample shampoo bars preferred this recipe over the others. This recipe makes a standard three pound soap loaf, which yields approximately ten bars of soap, depending upon how it is sliced.

The Best Shampoo Bar Recipe

Makes one loaf of shampoo soap, slightly less than three pounds, or approximately 10 bars

  • Olive oil – 16 oz
  • Coconut oil – 12 oz
  • Castor oil – 2 oz
  • Cocoa Butter – 2 oz
  • Sodium Hydroxide – 4.65 oz
  • Beer, left out overnight to go flat – 11 oz.
  • Fragrance or essential oils – .5 – 2 oz., according to preference
11 ounces of very flat beer make up the liquid component of the shampoo bar recipe. After spending a night in a shallow dish to release carbonation and alcohol, I strained and refrigerated the flat beer until ready to use. Photo by Melanie Teegarden.

To start making the shampoo bars, you must begin the day before by pouring 11 ounces of beer into a shallow container and leaving out overnight to go flat. This also reduces the alcohol content of the beer significantly. The shallow container is necessary because more carbonation will be released from the greater surface area exposed. Also, alcohol acts to suppress bubbles, so this is an important step. It is also important because if you add lye to fresh, bubbly beer it is likely to overflow — definitely not a situation you want to encounter. (To learn vital soapmaking safety protocols, click here.) I like to take the additional step of chilling the flat beer in the refrigerator for several hours before using. This prevents scorching of the sugars in the beer when the lye heating reaction occurs. In tests, there was always a small amount of undissolved lye sediment left over in the mixed solution, even after half an hour. I recommend straining the lye solution into the oils when you are ready to make soap.

Shampoo Bars

Here I must offer my sincere apologies, and an unusual suggestion — my apologies for the fact that mixing lye with beer releases an odor, a combination of yeast and wet dog. For this reason, I suggest mixing your lye solution outdoors, or at the very least, adjacent to an open window and with a fan running. The smell dissipates quickly in the finished soap and becomes completely undetectable when cured, leaving behind nothing but the benefits of added vitamins and minerals as well as richer shampoo lather.

Shampoo soap batter at medium trace will be the consistency of thin pudding. A “trace” of soap will lie on top of the batter when drizzled from a spoon or whisk, as seen here. Photo by Melanie Teegarden

When you are ready to make soap, first weigh all of your ingredients. Melt the hard oils (coconut and cocoa butter) together in the microwave or on a burner set over low heat. Warm until just melted enough to be clear oil, not opaque. Blend the melted oils with the room temperature soft oils (olive and castor) and allow the oils to rest until about 75-80 degrees Fahrenheit. Weigh out the beer and the sodium hydroxide. Very slowly pour the sodium hydroxide into the beer in a large bowl, while stirring, to allow for foaming to occur and subside. This may not happen if the beer is flat enough, but it is better to be safe and leave room for the reaction to happen. In our tests, there was always some amount of foaming when the lye was added. Allow the beer and lye solution to cool to room temperature before straining into the base oils. Mix the oils and strained lye solution thoroughly by hand using a nonreactive (non-aluminum) spoon or spatula. Next, use your stick blender in short bursts of 20-30 seconds, alternating with hand stirring, to help the shampoo soap reach medium trace. Once medium trace is reached, add the fragrance, if using, and mix thoroughly. Pour into the prepared mold. If the soap begins to get too hot during gel phase, you can place the soap into the refrigerator or freezer until it cools. This soap hardens fairly quickly and can crumble if cut when cured, so make sure you cut the soap as soon as it is firm enough.

The finished shampoo loaf is already beginning to lighten up in color. The cured soap was ivory in color. Photo by Melanie Teegarden

To use a shampoo bar, simply rub into wet hair, massage into scalp, then spread out to the ends before rinsing well. An optional acid rinse, such as a splash of vinegar or lemon juice in water, will make hair feel soft and well conditioned without adding residue.Some people like to infuse apple cider vinegar with herbs or essential oils to make their hair rinse more fragrant.To make a simple infusion for hair vinegar, pack a clean jar with fresh, dry herb leaves, stems and flowers. Fill with apple cider vinegar and cap. You can also add a few drops of essential oils to boost the fragrance of your infusion. Allow at least 48 hours for the infusion to develop before straining and storing in the bath. To use, add a splash to a cup and fill with warm water. Pour through hair. No need to rinse.

I have light colored hair, so I used lemon juice for my acid rinse base. Lavender buds, chamomile flowers, mint and lemon thyme add a soft fragrance. Photo by Melanie Teegarden.

By using our recipe, which is low in unsaponifiables that can make hair sticky, and also low in superfat, which can weigh hair down, you can create a good all-purpose shampoo bar suitable for most hair types. An additional acidic rinse will leave hair soft and silky.

Will you try making solid shampoo bars with our recipe? What fragrance or essential oils will you choose? Which herbs will you use in your acid rinse solution? We would be very interested to hear your results.

Ask the Expert

Do you have a soapmaking question? You’re not alone! Check here to see if your question has already been answered. And, if not, use our chat feature to contact our experts!

Hi for making shampoo bars, what can be the alternative to beer how much is to be used? – Keneez

You can use water, ounce for ounce, as a replacement for the beer. Many other liquids could also be used the same way, but you have to consider the amounts of sugar, sodium, and carbonation present in your chosen liquids. Therefore, if there is a specific liquid you wish to use besides plain water, we will have to consider it individually. – Melanie

15 thoughts on “Making Shampoo Bars”
    1. Hello Uma. I asked the author your question and here’s her answer:

      Shampoo bars, just like soap bars, need to cure for 6 weeks. This allows the bars to dry out and harden so that they are longer-lasting, and it also allows the ph of the shampoo bar to lower a bit, making it better for the hair.

      Thank you and have a great day!

  1. “Always add dry lye to the water; never add water to the lye. Pouring water onto the lye can result in caustic splashes”. This is just not true. You get irritating caustic fumes when adding lye to water due to the very swift chemical because ions diffusing in water move almost instantaneously. Adding water to the lye in gentle stream results in very few fumes (slower reaction), and if you pour gently and steadily there will be no “splashes”. I have done this for years, on the advice of my mother who had been a chemist.

    I’m not sure why the problematic myth of adding lye to the water persists, but the resulting fumes are toxic and irritating.

  2. Hi, I wonder why does bar shampoo needs to reach the specific medium trace, unlike bar soap that may go from light to heavy? Thank you.

    1. Hi, when it comes to liquids, you can substitute kinds of milk, flat wine, water, etc. Check the oils and lye through a soap calculator to be sure they are in a good balance so the soap isn’t caustic. And if that looks good, just swap the beer straight over for water.

    1. Hi Saranya,
      No, you cannot, unless you reformulate the recipe. Olive oil pomace has a different saponification value as straight olive oil … but you can substitute the cheapest olive oil instead of using extra-virgin. To reformulate, find a good online soap calculator.

    1. Hi Sheri, technically you can use goat milk and you can hot process, but since the recipe already uses an ingredient with sugars, I would pay extra attention to keep the sugar from burning. In hot process, the soap gets more than hot enough to burn.

  3. I’ve been making body soap for years. I want to try making shampoo bar. Can I use lard or beef tallow for shampoo or not? Thanks.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *